The environmental law that three states and a Texas city have used to stall plans for federal warehouse detention camps would lose much of its power in court under a permitting bill nearing a final vote in the senate.
The text of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act — also known as BAAJA — indicates that the four lawsuits already playing out in federal court over warehouses in Williamsport, Md.; Roxbury, N.J.; Surprise, Ariz.; and San Antonio, would continue under current law.
But the outcome of these cases — and any future cases like them — rely on an environmental review currently required by the National Environmental Policy Act, or NEPA, that the federal government has not finished.
If that review is completed after the bill becomes law, a challenge to it could face rules that make it far harder for a judge to stop a project.
BAAJA is a 400-plus-page rewrite of federal permitting law aimed mostly at energy and infrastructure projects. Senators voted 65 to 31 on Wednesday to end debate on the bill, clearing the 60-vote threshold and setting up a final Senate vote.
The House would still need to pass it and President Trump would need to sign it.
Project Salt Box has reviewed the managers’ amendment that senators are now considering, along with Congressional Research Service analysis of the bill and court records in each of the four cases.
What the bill would change
All four lawsuits currently rely on NEPA, a 1970 law that requires federal agencies to study the environmental effects of major projects and share that analysis with the public before undertaking any action.
Under current law, people challenging an agency’s compliance usually sue in federal district court under the Administrative Procedure Act, or APA, and have six years to file.
But Section 1110 of BAAJA would add a new judicial review section to NEPA. Any challenge to a federal project would have to be filed within 150 days after the agency’s decision is made public.
From there, the case would go directly to a federal appeals court instead of a district court. And in most cases, the only remedy a court could order for a NEPA violation would be to send the decision back to the original agency, “without vacatur or issuance of an injunction” — meaning a judge could not cancel the agency’s decision and could not order the project to stop — and with a deadline of no more than 180 days to fix it.
Meanwhile, the agency’s approval would stay in effect while it made those corrections.
The bill would allow a preliminary injunction only if a judge found a substantial likelihood that the project violates a federal law other than NEPA or the National Historic Preservation Act. A plaintiff would also have to show irreparable harm and that the balance of equities and the public interest favor an injunction.
That means a NEPA violation alone — the main basis for the court orders and agreements that have paused the warehouse projects — could no longer support one.
The new rules would apply only to claims “filed on or after the date of enactment.” Project Salt Box found no language in the published text of the bill’s NEPA section that addresses cases already pending when it becomes law.
BAAJA would also make it easier for agencies to skip a detailed environmental study. Many federal agencies already keep lists of routine work that is exempt from that study. Under BAAJA, an agency could combine several of those exemptions to cover one project and could use exemptions written by Congress, according to the Congressional Research Service.
That’s exactly the approach ICE tried from the start in Williamsport, where it claimed three exemptions to cover the purchase and renovation of the warehouse. A federal judge in Maryland rejected that argument in April.
A quick update on the warehouse cases
In Williamsport, Md., the Department of Homeland Security bought a 54-acre warehouse near $102.4 million on Jan. 16. Attorney General Anthony G. Brown sued on Feb. 23. Judge Brendan A. Hurson of the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland issued a temporary restraining order in March and a preliminary injunction in April.
DHS argued that the project was a real estate purchase requiring only minor renovations that qualified for a categorical exclusion. In June, the agency opened a public comment period on a new environmental assessment for a 1,500-bed facility. In comments filed July 1, Brown argued that the agency must prepare a full environmental impact statement and urged it to sell the property. The project remains stalled pending the completion of an environmental assessment.
The New Jersey Attorney General and Roxbury Township jointly sued on March 20 over a 470,000-square-foot warehouse in Morris County. Under the provisions of a May 12 agreement between the AG and DHS in lieu of a restraining order, the government may not convert the building until it completes an environmental assessment and issues a decision based on it. The angreement also maintains the state’s right to challenge that assessment in a renewed motion for a preliminary injunction.
In a joint status report filed Monday, the plaintiffs said DHS may have violated that agreement by issuing a $31.8 million contract on Nov. 5, first reported by Project Salt Box, that covers maintenance, design, and NEPA analysis at the site. The government said it would follow the process in the May 12 order.
In Arizona, Attorney General Kris Mayes sued the federal government on April 24 over a 418,400-square-foot warehouse the department bought for about $70 million.
That case has been at a standstill since a July 8 order — similar to the one in Roxbury — which stipulates that the government will not detain anyone at the warehouse or physically convert it until it completes a final environmental assessment.
But on Nov. 5, DHS filed a status report indicating it had completed a preliminary draft of the environmental assessment which found the warehouse conversion would cause no significant impact to the environment, and was weighing a decision to proceed with the conversion.
Once the state receives the final decision from DHS, it has 10 days to decide whether to seek a preliminary injunction.
The city of San Antonio sued on Oct. 13 over a 640,000-square-foot warehouse at 542 SE Loop 410 that the department bought for $66.1 million earlier this year. City officials said on Nov. 9 that they were negotiating with the Justice Department over an agreement to pause the case while environmental reviews are done. No agreement had been finalized.
What does BAAJA mean for the warehouse cases?
If DHS releases an environmental assessment in amy of those cases after BAAJA becomes law, the bill as written does not clearly say whether a challenge to it would be treated as part of the original lawsuit — and the old law — or as a new claim under the new one.
As a new claim, it would be subject to the 150-day deadline. It would have to be filed in a federal appeals court, and could not produce an injunction based on NEPA alone. And in that case, work would proceed as the case is worked out.
Several of the suits also include claims under other laws. New Jersey’s complaint, for example, cites the Immigration and Nationality Act and the Intergovernmental Cooperation Act. Under the bill, claims like those could still support a preliminary injunction if a court found them strong enough.
So far, though, NEPA has been the central pillar in these cases. The Maryland injunction issued by Judge Hurson and the pauses in New Jersey and Arizona all hinge on the government’s failure to finish an environmental review.
The government is working to sell its seven remaining warehouses — part of what it calls the Federal Warehouse Portfolio, brokered by Wakeman & Cushfield. If it reverses course and retains any of the properties — for example, after a sale falls through — any new challenges to plans for those buildings would be subject to the new rules if the bill becomes law.
And thus, unlikely to succeed.
What do supporters and critics say?
Sen. Shelley Moore Capito, a West Virginia Republican who chairs the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, has said environmental reviews should be “tools for informed decision-making, not reasons that decisions can’t be made.” Supporters of BAAJA argue the bill would speed approval of power lines, transit systems, and other clean energy projects that have faced years of permitting delays.
But Detention Watch Network, a coalition opposed to immigration detention, has urged Congress to reject the bill, arguing it would make detention facilities “easier to build and much harder to stop.”
Earthjustice, which represented local groups that filed a brief supporting Maryland’s request for an injunction, has similarly argued that the bill’s limits on legal remedies would apply to lawsuits under the Administrative Procedure Act seeking to enforce the National Environmental Policy Act — the kinds of lawsuits that were filed in challenges to the ICE’s warehouses.
Some supporters have disputed critics’ claims about the bill’s potential effect on detention facilities. An analyst with the Breakthrough Institute, a research group that supports permitting changes, wrote that NEPA litigation has halted construction or conversion at only a handful of detention centers.
The projects in these lawsuits, however, are not conventional detention centers built for that purpose. They are vacant industrial warehouses that the government bought to convert into detention camps.
A government contractor told Project Salt Box and NPR that the warehouse plan came from an administration push to make detention harsh. The contractor told NPR he understood that Stephen Miller, the White House deputy chief of staff, wanted the facilities to be “difficult and painful,” while telling Project Salt Box that “cruelty” was the policy.
Because the warehouse strategy is new, the small number of NEPA cases so far may say little about what the bill would change. The larger question is how it would affect the government’s ability to quickly turn industrial shells into places to hold human beings.



Thanks very much much for this sharp, detailed -and sobering - analysis PSB!
Your blog inspired this StoryMap in which I've cited Project Salt Box.
Republicans are using BAAJA to weaken NEPA and strip communities of legal tools to stop ICE detention centers. Follow our interactive map of the plan. Call your rep: STOP BAAJA.
https://thedemlabs.org/2026/11/19/baaja-ice-detention-expansion-nepa-map/